Yardbarker
MLB futures: Can Gerrit Cole hit the Over on K's in 2024?
New York Yankees starting pitcher Gerrit Cole (45). Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

MLB futures: Can Gerrit Cole hit the Over on K's in 2024?

For all the things that went wrong for the New York Yankees last season, the one thing that went right was Gerrit Cole. So, of course, he's a player oddsmakers have their eyes on ahead of the 2024 MLB season.

The veteran right-hander deservedly won the AL Cy Young Award after leading the American League with a 2.63 ERA (second only to NL Cy Young winner Blake Snell) and leading the entire league with a 0.98 WHIP and 24 quality starts. He also ranked fifth in the league with 222 strikeouts, which marked the third consecutive season Cole tallied more than 200 Ks — and that's an area sportsbooks and bettors alike enjoy zeroing in on.

DraftKings has set the over/under for strikeouts Cole will throw this season at 215.5 and lists the Over favorable at -115. Given his recent track record, this number seems very reachable. Then again, Cole is 33 and could be entering that point in a pitcher's career where those numbers begin to dip. 

So what's the safe bet when it comes to Cole's over/under for strikeouts in 2024?

MLB.com contributor Brian Murphy thinks Cole will be a strikeout leader once again in 2024 even though the starter is getting older, citing Cole's consistency. And if Cole stays consistent — and healthy — then betting he will register over 215.5 strikeouts sounds like a good bet.

"The two-time MLB strikeout king is still the game’s most reliable pitcher when it comes to racking up the K’s," Murphy said. "Cole’s 1,418 strikeouts since the start of 2018 are 200 more than anyone else, and he has averaged 265 K’s over the last five full seasons."



Check out Yardbarker's betting hub for more previews, predictions, news and analysis.


Pinstripe Alley makes a similar argument. They note that the small dip in velocity Cole's fastball last year was also met with consistency due to adjustments he has made to stay in the starting rotation longer.

"After more consistently throwing his heater up in the zone, and less in the heart, Cole saw more overall success with the pitch despite getting fewer whiffs," the site says. "As he enters his mid-30s, redefining how he uses the unique properties of his four-seamer will be crucial for him to sustain long-term health." 

They add: "Taking off a little juice may have hurt the whiff and strikeout profile of the pitch, but the gains on command and health sustainability will prove to be a good decision for Cole."

As Yardbarker has said before , no one can predict how healthy a team or its players will be before the season starts. However, it looks like Gerrit Cole is already taking strides to ensure he continues to be a healthy starting pitcher. With that in mind, there is plenty of reason to believe he can hit DK's over on strikeouts for 2024. 

We'll just have to see how he does in his first outing in the regular season. He's got to be the Opening Day starter after winning the AL Cy Young and posted 222 strikeouts, right? 

More must-reads:

Sign up for the Bark Bets Newsletter

Bark Bets is Yardbarker's free daily guide to the world of sports betting. You'll get:

  • Picks and predictions from our in-house experts
  • The last-minute updates that give you an edge
  • Special offers from Sportsbooks

Subscribe now!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.